En esta canción oscura, Clarkson lamenta su relación con un hombre que le ha roto su corazón al que no le importa las lágrimas que ella ha llorado, detrás de sus ojos pardos. Las líricas de la canción están basadas en una historia verdadera, y son de un ex-novio de Clarkson (David Hodges de Evanescence) que la dejó para casarse con su ex-novia.
Seems like just yesterday You were a part of me I used to stand so tall I used to be so strong Your arms around me tight Everything, it feel so right Unbreakable, like nothin' could go wrong Now I can't breathe No, I can't sleep I'm barely hanging on Here I am, once again I'm torn into pieces Can't deny it, can't pretend Just thought you were the one Broken up, deep inside But you won't get to see the tears I cry Behind these hazel eyes I told you everything Opened up and let you in You made me feel alright For once in my life now all that's left of me is what I pretend to be So toghether, but so broken up inside cause I can't sleep I'm barely hangin' on Here i am, once again I'm torn into pieces Can't deny it, can't pretend Just thought you were the one Broken up deep inside But tou wan't get to see the tears I cry Behind these hazel eyes Swallow me then spit me out For hating you, I blame myself Seeing you it kills me now No, I don't cry on the outside Anymore... Here I am, once again I'm torn into pieces Can't deny it, can't pretend Just thouht you were the one Broken up deep inside But you won't get to see the tears I cry Behind these hazel eyes Here I am, once again I'm torn into pieces Can't deny it, can't pretend Just thouht you were the one Broken up deep inside But you won't get to see the tears I cry Behind these hazel eyes